School Reform or Reform School?

The third grade Virginia Standards of Learning in Social Studies (Virginia’s version of the Common Core) define community as a place where people work, live, and play (3.10).  This definition is too limited.  Community is deep and broad and soars through imagination.   It is what happens when like-minded people work together, or when people with differences turn their hearts and minds to common purpose.  Community is a place, but it is also a result.   Community’s parameters can be infinite with online communities and social networks, and yet, community remains the place where you are, the place where you care, and the place where you work with others to make a difference.

Words transform.  Words are big and beautiful and powerful.  They help us reach and they help us dig deep.  Words are the tools of the educated person. Words change hearts.  Words change minds.  And sometimes words change. Reform used to be a positive word.

John Dewey wrote, “What the best and wisest parent wants for his own child, that must the community want for all of its children.  Any other ideal for our schools is narrow and unlovely; acted upon, it destroys our democracy.”

John Dewey is not writing about a place where people live, work, and play.  He is writing about a group of concerned citizens who pool their sense of possibility for all.   Idea is only one letter short of ideal, but it can be so much narrower.  No one would call “school reform” an ideal.  It is a movement without grace.  I have watched this idea of reform intently as I have held on to my ideal of public education.  There is less talk about citizens and more talk about “workers.”   Reformers say that our graduates are not “work ready,” and yet our current graduates are the result of  this school reform.

The goal posts move.  It is not enough for our schools to pass; children have to continue to pass at higher rates every year or a school doesn’t “show improvement.”    And now the tests are changing to show “critical thinking.”  This leaves me to wonder if the meaning of critical thinking has changed, too.  Language is crucial to critical thinking.  Test-ready definitions are too narrow and result in narrow thinking– the antithesis of critical thinking.

We need standards.  We need common standards.  We need high standards.  Standards guide what we teach, but they should not be used to bully administrators, teachers, and children.  They should guide conversation and experience and expand our intellectual lexicon. School reform should not turn our classrooms into reform schools.   True school improvement is not an abstract policy movement about educating other people’s children.  Real school improvement is grounded in the reflective practice of real teachers who are passionate about what works for our children.   Class size matters in this work.  Effective classrooms are places rich with language and literature and ideas and problem solving.  The health of our community depends on it.

About these ads

About Annie Campbell

Annie Campbell is a third grade teacher and loves her work. She especially enjoys teaching children how to be enthusiastic readers, writers, and problem solvers. Every year, she hopes to inspire her students to be committed citizens who know they can make a difference in the world around them. When she is not teaching, Annie enjoys cooking for family and friends; she likes to lose herself in a good book; she loves discovering new ideas, restaurants, perfect picnic places, and movies with her husband, Ben.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to School Reform or Reform School?

  1. Del Sledge says:

    So beautiful! So Annie!

  2. Daniela Jacobs says:

    Well said Annie! I agree completely! :)

  3. susanbarstow says:

    Annie, You are such a beautiful and inspiring writer. No, school reform should not turn our schools into reform schools. Yes, classroom size matters, teachers matter, words matter and children matter. Thank you for your passion, your anger and your hope.

  4. Nancy B says:

    Excellent blog! These are some of the same reasons I work passionately to have a positive impact on the children I come across every day, whether it’s my own 3rd grader, her friends and schoolmates, my neighbors, or kids in the park or at the grocery store. I want the best community, not only for my daughter, but for EVERYONE!! And that cannot be accomplished when we treat people as a commodity or when we try to fit all children to a mold rather than working with their unique, wonderful personalities.

  5. Gena says:

    Annie-you speak from such deep + real presence, deep + real experience in the classroom. thank you for that perspective that can only come from that place. – Gena xo

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s